An environmental issue is referenced up to 20 times in every newspaper in the United States. These articles may be about obvious environmental issues such as water quality or ecological issues such as changing weather patterns. The scope of environmental science can also be social, political, and technological. It is impossible to write an article that does not possess bias. As a surveyor of environmental publications and information, it is your job to read critically and recognize bias.
Sunday, October 31, 2010
A Big Bet on Natural Gas
Monday, October 18, 2010
Tuesday, October 5, 2010
Could Genetically Altered Tree, Plants Help Counter Global Warming?
October 2, 2010
A study done by researchers a Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory come up with a strategy to try and counter act global warming by genetically engineering trees. This process could not only increase the plants efficiency to absorb light, but also alter the plants so that they send more carbon to their roots. This could also alter the plants so that they are better able to withstand “stresses of growing on marginal land”
This article shows bias because it emphasized global warming. It also states that, genetically engineered plants is the one of the only ways to boost carbon sequestration. The article does not present the potential negative effects of genetically engineered plants or the other options.
This article applies to: II-B: energy flow, IV- A: agriculture, B: forestry, VII- B: Global Warming.
Julie Wegmann period 7
Monday, October 4, 2010
Greenhouse gases
Greenhouse gasses are at an extreme high due to China and India's increasing use of coal power. If this keeps increasing, the effect on the Earth will be irreversible. Basically, the release of carbon dioxide is harmful but it is part of nature. It’s bad though that our contribution had lead to a tipping point. There wasn’t really any bias besides blaming the increase of greenhouse gases on China and India when it’s really everyone who is using a lot of coal and putting a lot of carbon dioxide into the air. The article was pro environmentalist. It is warning to us, but at the same time, it tells us that as a whole we aren’t doing much since there hasn’t been a decline of emission.
V. Energy Resources and Consumption
C. Fossil Fuel Resources and Use
VII. Global Changes
B. Global Warning
State grants air pollution permits for Matagorda plant
This article, published in the Houston Chronicle addresses the approval of a coal burning power plant in Matagorda. While the company still needs to get several other permits approved, locals are vehemently opposed to the building of the plant. They say that it will consume large amounts of fresh water, and have an impact on the recreational environment.
The opinions that are offered in the article are all from locals, who oppose the plant. The author of the article definitely leans towards the environmentalist side, placing special emphasis on local officials and their environmental concerns. He also mentions some of the possible setbacks the company may face in building the plant.
I. B. atmospheric composition.
I. C. industrial water use
II. A. Keystone species and destruction of species
II. E. Carbon cycle
III. B. 2. Sustainability
IV. D. 3. wildlife management
IV. D. 4. Land preservation
V. B. Industrial revolution
V. C. Fossil fuel, coal
IV. A. 1. Air pollution, primary
IV. B. Environmental risks
VII. A. ozone depletion
VII. B. Global warming, greenhouse gasses
VII. C. Habitat loss
Baby Loggerhead Turtles had to be moved from their Gulf Coast homes before the hatched because the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico would lower their chance of survival. Thousands of locals from Alabama, Mississippi, Louisiana, and Florida helped to move the eggs before they hatched. The eggs were moved to the Atlantic coast of Florida.
Source: The New York Times, October 3, 2010
The author holds a bias against the oil spill and BP since he takes an interest in the kindness of the Gulf natives and their help to save sea turtles. This is a pro environmentalist article.
Relates to: I. C. ( Global Water) and VI. A. 3. (Water Pollution)
U.S. Issues New Rules on Offshore Drilling
The article is written by John Broder of the New York Times and is dated September 30, 2010.
The article is written in a way that it criticizes the oil executives for the oil spills that have happened over the past year. It makes them out to seem irresponsible, only caring about there income rather than the environment.
V. Energy Resources and Consumption
C. Fossil Fuel Resources and Use
VI. Pollution
B. Impacts on the Environment and Human Health
2. Hazardous chemicals in the environment
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/01/us/01drill.html?_r=1&ref=earth
Douglas McNiel Apes in the News
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2010/09/100928154754.htm
Professor Christopher J. Gobler, Ph.D., and Ph.D. candidate Stephanie Talmage conducted experiments to assess the impacts of ocean acidification on clams, scallops, and other selfish. They determined that the acidification of our oceans (due to the rising amount of carbon dioxide) could be contributing to the decline in these species. This article was found on the Science Daily website, and was composed September 29, 2010. The writers seem somewhat biased to that humans can help prevent the amount of excess carbon dioxide in the air. The authors seem to be pro-environmentalist. This article is applicable to our study of environmental science through the carbon cycle and extinction.
A stormy year for sea turtles
Water Use in Southwest Heads for a Day of Reckoning
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/09/28/science/earth/28mead.html?ref=earth
After suffering an 11- year drought throughout the Southwest, the Colorado River is not able to keep up with the regions demands for more water. Lake Mead, the center of the lower Colorado basin’s water system, is in danger of dropping below the crucial demarcation line of 1,075 feet. If this happens, a temporary distribution plan will be put into place in seven states by the federal Bureau of Reclamation. As a result, there will be more dry lawns, shorter showers, and fallow fields in states such as Arizona or Nevada. This plan will help water managers send more water than usual downstream to Lake Mead and the levels will be restored. This is the lowest the river has been in 100 plus years, but back then there was a significantly lower demand for water due to the smaller population. One of the major cities that will be affected by the distribution is Las Vegas, which relies on Lake Mead for 90% of its water.
New York Times- September 27, 2010
This article is not necessarily biased, but the author clearly states the consequences if we do not start conserving water in the Southwestern part of the country. The article is pro environmentalist and agrees that conservation is crucial.
I
C. Global Water Resources and Use
IV
A. Agriculture
1. Feeding a growing population
Wildfires: A Symptom of Climate Change
published by nasa.gov
posted September 24, 2010
With an increase in wildfires, scientists believe they are a symptom of Global Warming. Most of the fires are in fact “human instigated”. The extent of damage from the fires varies from each ecosystem. Some biomass is more combustible, while others burn at higher temperatures. Any burning biomass releases harmful chemicals or gases, such as carbon monoxide, and can threaten the health of humans.
The author clearly states facts found from scientists, but also writes about one mans experience with a close encounter of a wildfire. The man describes it as eerie, and although knows it is environmentally harmful, seems to enjoy the view of burning Earth. However, there is little to now bias in the article.
I. Earth Systems and Resources
B. The Atmosphere
II. The Living World
C. Ecosystem diversity
III.Land and Water Use
B. Forestry
IV. Pollution
A. Air Pollution
B. Impacts on the Environment and Human Health
1. Hazards to Human Health
V. Global Change
A. Stratospheric Ozone
B. Global Warming
C. Loss of Biodiversity
1. Habitat loss
Ike Dike
Downtown Los Angeles bakes at record 113 degrees
West coast weather patterns indicate a major heat wave, causing the temperature in Los Angeles to exceed their record of 112 degrees on Monday, September 27, 2010. This caused electrical demand to increase throughout the state, peaking the amount of megawatts ever used there at one time. According to the National Weather Service, the cause of this heat wave is dry heat being created by a ridge of high pressure over the West coast.
Houston Chronicle- September 27, 2010
While mainly sticking to the facts, the author has a clear opinion that it is not a big deal that the temperature has risen by so many degrees. He even states that the high temperature is, "not all that remarkable," for the people of Southern California, an opinion he bases the article off of.
I. Earth Systems and Resources
B. The Atmosphere
V. Energy Resources and Consumption
B. Energy Consumption
Could Genetically Altered Trees, Plants Counter Global Warming
- Carbon Cycle
Naples' Trash Problem
Time Magazine
October 2, 2010
Naples, Italy is having problems with disposal of trash. The landfills are overflowing, and there is no place to put the trash, which is covering the streets and sidewalks at present time. The government speaks of opening a landfill around Mount Vesuvius National Park, but the population is outraged because of the issues it would cause for the environment and for the community. It has been calculated that Naples is the world’s largest waste producer per square meter, but without anything to deal with it. All of the proposed solutions are quick fixes, but won’t last long; what the city needs is a reevaluation of their long-term waste plans.
The bias lays in the author’s negative opinion of the measures being taken to solve the problem in Naples. It is obvious that he leans towards the environmentalist side and against the actions that the government is currently taking.
VI. Pollution
A. Pollution Types
4. Solid Waste
B. Impacts on the Environment and Human Health
1. Hazards to human health
Sunday, October 3, 2010
Too Much Lion and Leopard Trophy Hunts
'Trophy lion' hunts unsustainable
Trophy hunters are killing too many lions and leopards in Tanzania, a country were they have hunting blocks in which tourists hunt for sport. Hunting in these blocks is meant to regulate the overpopulation of the cats but is actually causing their population to decline since people are hunting mostly the older males, which are necessary for breeding and producing more offspring. Even if Tanzania is now doing something about it, some other parts of Africa don’t have a budget that allows them to protect more of their holdings and pay salaries of their game scouts.
This article is from BBC Earth News and was published on 13 September 2010.
This article is biased against the companies who are not doing much about lion and leopard hunting. They blame over-hunting for sport as the reason why lions and leopards are diminishing in population, which could not necessarily be the only reason for their decrease in numbers. There are other factors that could play into their decrease in numbers. This article is pro-environmentalist because it is trying to let the reader know that if the lions and leopards are over-hunted, this could affect the population of each species, which could change the environment for the worse.
II. The Living World
A. Ecosystem Structure (Biological population and communities; ecological niche)
B. Ecosystem Diversity (Biodiversity; natural selection)
VII. Global Change
A. Loss of Biodiversity
- Extinct species
- Maintenance through conservation
Is Water Enough for Life to Begin?
The Christian Post Sun, Oct. 03 2010 10:31 PM
The biggest issue noted in this article is the overriding question: Can life begin anywhere water is? Steven Vogt claims that the planet he has found (Gliese 581g) with a full team of astronomers definitely has tiny bacteria living on it due to the fact that water is found. There is some definite skepticism because there is no way to actually tell whether there is bacteria living because the planet in actuality is 120 trillion miles away.
This article appears to have no bias because it argues for both sides of the arguments. One being that life begins through divine interactions and the other being that it exists over time with no fine tuning necessary. The article talks about how their are scientists who believe water is the only necessity and others who believe there are over 300 minimal requirements for life to begin.
VII. Global Change
II. The Living World
The Battle is being lost to save the Tiger.
This article deals with the loss of the tiger through hunting and habitat loss throughout the world. This research is centered around Interpol and their attempted enforcement of the CITES Treaty. WHich forbids the trade of endangered and exotic animal parts. The tiger falls under this heading and the article was published to raise awareness to the fact that only 3,200 of this animals still roam wild. Breeding operations in China, in which the tigers where being raised to have parts sold also came under scrutiny. CITES officials lamented the poor enforcement of the anti-trading laws.
This article comes from the BBC website, written by correspondent Richard Black. Posted March 15, 2010.
Opinions are scarce throughout this article, but the writer is sympathetic to the cause of the CITES officials and of the tiger itself. It admonishes the behaviour of all the poachers and of the Chinese farmers. This article is pro environmentalist.
It is relevant in the following sub-sections:
II. The Living World.
A. Ecosystem Structure.
C. Ecological DIversity.
III. Population
A. Population Biology Concepts.
VII. Global Change
C. Loss of biodiversity
1. Habitat loss, endangered and extinct species.
3. Relevant laws and treaties.
- Jon Hancock.
NOAA reopens more than 5,000 square miles in the Gulf of Mexico to Fishing
BP Texas City Aftermath
British Petroleum has agreed to pay a $15 million sum to compensate for its breaking of the Clean Air Act in Texas City, Texas. The explosion and ensuing fire at the plant, which killed 15 workers back in 2005, is one of BP's many recent violations of federal environmental laws.
Environmental News Network, Andy Soos, October 1, 2010
This article can be viewed as biased simply because of the organization it originated from. The Environmental News Network has a pro-environmentalist lean, with the theme of the website being the color green, its certification as a green website, and the advertisements for environmentally friendly SmartCars on the site. The article itself stays fairly neutral up until the end where the author lets his personal opinion close the article with "Money is not everything but is one way to assess blame and incur punishment. It can only be hoped that this was enough." The journalists clearly has a unfavorable view of BP and clearly believes they should be punished heavily for their violations.
V. Energy Resources and Consumption
B. Energy Consumption - 2. Present Global Energy Use
C. Fossil Fuel Resources and Use - Natural Gas, Extraction/Purification
VI. Pollution
A. Pollution Types - 1. Air Pollution
B. Impacts on Human Health
Ancient Italian Town Has Wind at its Back
Ancient Italian Town Has Wind at Its Back
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/09/29/science/earth/29fossil.html?ref=science
The people of the small town of Tocco Da Casauria, Italy have decided to try a new wind turbine method for obtaining energy. The town uses wind turbines to power the ancient cemetery and the sport complexes. Because they were forced to pay huge electricity bills and there are not many energy sources in Italy, they turned to renewable energy. Over the last year, Tocco has been building wind turbines and solar panels over the old olive groves in order to stray away from the high fossil fuel prices. They are converting the city from using electricity into using the power from the sun and the wind, and because of this, other small cities are being inspired to do the same. This was talked about on September 29, 2010 reported by Elisabeth Rosenthal.
The opinions are offered when explaining how little energy Italy naturally has and how expensive and destructive it is to the environment. The opinion is that this is a great start to a new king of renewable energy source that Italy will benefit from. The direction is very positive, hoping that this experiment will last and help the community. It is very pro environmentalist because the reporter shows how she is very accepting of new forms of energy instead of burning fossil fuels. In conclusion, it is said that “Tocco itself was primed for success” , and this is because with increasing technology wind and solar panels could be a very realistic was of powering whole cities.
III. Population
B. Human Population
1. Growth rates and doubling times
2. Population size- strategies for sustainability
3. Impacts of population growth- resource use
IV. Land and Water Use
D. Other land use
1.planned development
V. Energy Resources and Consumption
B. Energy Consumption
1. Industrial Revolution
2. Energy crisis
C. Fossil Fuel Resources and Use
3. World Reserves and global demand
F. Energy Conservation
1. Energy Efficiency
G. Renewable Energy
5. Wind energy
VVI. Global Change
B. Global warming
1. greenhouse gases and the greenhouse effect
-Erin MacInerney
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/09/19/science/earth/19clean.html?_r=1&scp=3&sq=environment&st=cse
This article was written by Mireya Navarro on September 18, 2010. It can be found on the New York Times website.
The article deals with household detergents, dishwasher in particular, and the effects they have on the environment. It also talks about the changes that have been made in the ingredients of dishwasher detergents. The ingredients of the cleaner include a large amount of phosphate which is meant to keep spots off of the dishes. However, although the phosphates make dishes look good, they are know to damage the environment in some situations. The detergent company, Cascade, reduced the phosphate level from 8.7% to 0.5% in accordance with laws that went into affect in 17 states. The first bias that I noticed in the article occurred when the author wrote about the effect of phosphate in the environment. The author says that large phosphate levels in lakes cause algae to overgrow. Algae overgrowth then causes fish to die because it takes away living space and reduces the amount of oxygen. Although phosphate might affect lake ecosystems, it is beneficial in many other ecosystems. Phosphate fertilizes plants and reduces the need for artificial fertilizers. In ecosystems where plant life is minimal, this large amount of phosphate released into the environment from detergents would be beneficial. The bias produced by the author is most likely directed to improve the sustainability of lake ecosystems. The article is clearly against the use of phosphates in dishwasher detergents. Although the author is against the use of phosphates, she is pro-environmental because she is frustrated with the effects of phosphate run-off in lakes and streams.
The article refers to I. Earth systems and resources C. Global Water Resources And Use. The article also refers to VI. Pollution A. Pollution Types 3. Water Pollution.
The Power of Green
This article stresses the negative connotation to the word "green" and how the society in America must work to change it. With the help of all Americans, environmental efforts can change from being used to separate parties and people to being used in order to unite them in fixing the problems of jobs, temperature, and terrorism.
"The Power of Green" by Thomas L. Friedman, New York Times. April 15, 2007
This article is automatically pro- environmentalist because the theme of the article is to encourage everyone in the country to go green. He consistently writes about the importance of changing America's ways in order to be more environmentally friendly.
V. Energy Resources and Consumption
C. World Reserves and Global Demand
VI. Pollution
C. Sustainability
Ancient Italian Town Has Wind At Its Back
A small dirty town in Italy called Tocco da Casauria installed wind turbines and now not only produces green energy, but is also producing more than they need and making money off of the extra. The town decided to install these turbines because they were paying so much for electricity, three times what they average American paid. The article was written by Elisabeth Rosenthal on September 28, 2010. The author of the article demonstrates bias by praising the endeavors of this small town to use renewable energy. The article is pro environmentalist which is apparent because the author notes the fact that the town Tocco has won awards from international environmental groups for its efforts in renewable energy.
III Population: B human Population: Impacts of population growth (resource use)
V Energy Resources and Consumption: energy concepts, energy consumption, fossil fuel resources and use, energy conservation, renewable energy
VII Global Change: global warming
"New Planet May Be Able to Nurture Organisms"
On September 29, 2010, Astronomer Dr. Steven S. Vogt helped discover a planet in the Libra constellation that is thought to be able to support life. The planet, Gliese 581g, is located in prime location in comparison to the star it orbits where the temperature is not too hot or too cold. Although the possibility is exciting, the planet may not be able to support more life than simple lichens, and several factors, including the greenhouse effect, may stifle the high expectations for the newfound earth-like planet.
The bias in this article is very subtle, and therefore, quite balanced. It gives positive review of the discovery, sparking giddy enthusiasm in the reader. It balances this out by presenting possible flaws in the new discovery. The bias isn't particularily pro or con environmentalist. It's more premature exciment vs. facts of deeper investigation.
I. Earth Systems and Resources
A. Earth Science Concepts- solar intensity
B. The Atmosphere- composition
C. Global Water Resources and Use- surface and groundwater issues
III. Population
A. Population Biology Concepts- survivorship
VII. Global Change
B. Global Warming- greenhouse gasses and the greenhouse effect
~Calhan Hale
Vanishing California Sea Otters- Mary Jacobs
Acid Rain 30 Years On
EPA Gets Tough on Chesapeake Bay Cleanup
The article is from About.com, written on September 29th, 2010.
The Environmental Protection Agency is becoming more strict on the states that have been polluting the Chesapeake Bay. Virginia, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Delaware and New York have been ignoring the federal warnings for more than 27 years. Now, they have until November 29th to make their cleaning habits better or the EPA will increase sewer bills and raise property taxes.
This article was mostly informative, however, it was apparent that the writer is pro-environmentalist because there was a since of frustration while talking about how the EPA has done nothing to punish the states who have not complied to the federal warnings.
VII. Pollution
A. Pollution Types
3. Water Pollution
Environmentalists pan first drilling permit since lifting on shallow-water drilling ban
Environmentalists are disappointed in the new permit for drilling in the gulf while the BP oil spill is going on in the gulf. Peter Galvin, the director of the Center of Biological Diversity, and many other environmentalists believe that it is damaging the environment as much as the leaking Macondo well. They are bewilerdered at the fact that the administration is allowing more drilling. Despite this permit, Interior Secretary Ken Salazar, is making new safety rules and banning deeper water drilling.
Wednesday, June 2, 2010 at 6:09 PM by Tom Fowler in Deepwater Horizon accident
This article is bias because it is about environmentalists angry response to the drilling permit, and it is not argueing with their dissaproval. This article is clearly pro environmentalist.
I. Earth Systems and Resources
C. Global Water Resource and Use (surface and groundwater issues, industrial)
V. Energy Resources and Consumption
C. Fossil Fuel Resources and Use (formation of natural gas, Extraction methods)
Water fight: Cabot, Pa. officials spar over contamination claims
Renewable Energy-Highways
Penguin Fossils Change Previously Understood Knowledge of Feathers
Developing Nations to Get Clean-Burning Stoves
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/09/21/science/earth/21stove.html?_r=1&scp=8&sq=&st=nyt
Developing countries are receiving help from the United States and other countries in order to help reduce the harmful smoke primitive indoor stoves produce. Hilary Clinton is involved in the project known as the Global Alliance for Clean Cook-stoves that helps address the problem these stoves create. They are trying to generate enough of these in order to have a thriving global industry in cookstoves that are good for the environment.
New York Times, September 20,2010
By: John M. Broder
The article is more informative than anything else, some areas of bias come from the opinions of people that think the indoor stoves are not as environmental friendly. The bias is not specifically against the indoor stoves, it just only gives the positives of the eco- friendly stoves. The author is a pro environmentalist; you can conclude this by the opinions he shares about the stoves and the negative statistics he gives about the others.
I. Earth Systems and Resources
B. The Atmosphere
V. Energy Resources and Consumption
C. Fossil Fuel Resources and Use
F. Energy Conservation
VI. Pollution
A. Pollution Types
1. Air Pollution
B. Impacts on the Environment and Human Health
1. Hazards to human health
VII. Global Change
B. Global Warming (climate change)
"A Destructive Epidemic"
EPA Gets Tough on Chesapeake Bay Cleanup
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency is cracking down on Virginia, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Delaware, and New York for causing serious damage, from pollution, to the Chesapeake Bay. The states have until November 29, 2010 to "correct "serious deficiencies" in their cleanup plans or face consequences". Theses five states are the reason for more then 70 percent of all dead zones, which" cause harmful algae blooms that deprive fish, crabs and oysters of life- giving oxygen", in the Chesapeake Bay.
The article stated mostly the straight scientific facts, but did show some bias when stating the reactions of the five states to past attempts to get them to clean the Chesapeake. The article is very pro environmentalist and the authors opinion came out by showing support and sympathy towards the EPA for the neglect of the five states to clean up the Bay.
This article was published by About.com on September 29, 2010
VI. Pollution
A. Pollution Types
3 Water Pollution
Wind Turbines in Italy
California Toughens Energy Standards
California is currently pursuing its goal of 20 percent renewable energy standard by next year. However, regulations have been changed and now require energy utilities to draw one third of their energy from alternative, renewable resources such as wind and solar. Although many agree that raising the standard is a good idea, critics say the new regulations may not be effective because energy companies will now have more loopholes (that are not currently legal) to avoid reforming to new energy standards. There is also speculation on the effects this may have on the state in terms of jobs. Some believe that the new standard will increase green jobs, while others see a rise in electricity rates effectively killing jobs and raising the already high unemployment rates. Gov. Schwarzenegger agrees with regulators with the hope that the new requirement will comply with the 2006 Global Warming Law and reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
This article was reported by the Wall Street Journal on September 24, 2010. It is unbiased, showing all sides to the arguments over the energy standards and their effects on the state of California. The article is well rounded with both pro and con environmentalist opinions on the issues regulators are facing.
Topics List:
V. Energy Resources and Consumption
F. Energy Consumption
G. Renewable Energy
VI. Pollution
A. Pollution Types
1. Air Pollution
VII. Global Change
B. Global Change
-Kacey Cramer: Period 4
Lawsuit: Man who Tried to Save Drowning Toddler Became Ill from Oil
Extreme Heat Bleaches Coral, and Threat Is Seen
FDA to consider approval of modified salmon
62-mpg car standard by 2025? U.S. mulls options
By 2025, cars sold in the U.S. might have to have a standard fuel economy of 62 miles per gallon. The Obama administration revealed new mileage standards for 2017-2025 car models, ranging from a minimum of 47 mpg to a high of 62 mpg. While the cost of producing more fuel-efficient cars would be more expensive, reduced fuel costs over the lifetime of the car could equal $5,000 to $7,000. This standard would help reduce the effects of automobiles on climate change by reducing carbon emissions 3-6%, and curb the United States' dependency on foreign oil sources.
This article presents the facts objectively, but shows a slight bias towards the fuel economy legislation. Despite this, the article shows both the environmentalist's and auto manufacturer's side of the argument.
This article was published on MSNBC October 1st, 2010
V. Energy Resources and Consumption
B. Energy Consumption
C. Fossil Fuel Resources and Use
F. Energy Conservation
VI. Pollution
A. Pollution types
1. Air Pollution
C. Economic Impacts
VII. Global Change
B. Global Warming